
After months in Taliban detention, Afghan women’s rights activist Manizha Seddiqi was released. But the prison did not end when the door opened. Fear followed her into exile, while the pressure to remain silent continued.
By Fariba Faizi
When the prison door opened, Manizha Seddiqi did not feel free.
She had spent months in Taliban custody after being arrested in Kabul for her activism for the rights of Afghan women and girls. She came out carrying memories of interrogation, fear and uncertainty about what would happen to her family.
The walls of the prison were gone. But the fear remained.
Seddiqi had already learned that imprisonment was not the only way to silence a woman.
Before her arrest, she had lived cautiously, often moving between places and changing her appearance to avoid being followed. She worked at night as a nurse in an emergency department while taking part in civil and women’s rights activities during the day.
Her activism had grown out of a simple question: what would happen to Afghan girls’ futures if their schools and universities remained closed?
She had once dreamed of becoming a specialist in obstetrics and gynaecology. After the Taliban returned to power and women were pushed out of education, employment and public life, that dream became one of the reasons she protested.
She joined demonstrations, attended gatherings and continued speaking for women’s rights even as the space for protest became increasingly dangerous.
October 9, 2023
Then, on October 9, 2023, her life changed.
Seddiqi was on her way to meet a female colleague near Haji Yaqub intersection in Kabul’s Shahr-e-Naw area to discuss a protest in support of women activists who had already been detained.
Several men wearing traditional Afghan clothing and turbans surrounded her.
They took her phone, handcuffed her and covered her head with a black bag.
As she was being taken away, she heard someone speaking on the phone.
“Manizha Panjshiri has been arrested. The operation was completed successfully,” she recalls hearing.
She asked about the woman she had been going to meet. The men told her they did not know her.
According to Seddiqi, she was beaten and questioned about her phone and her contacts. She says she was accused of supporting resistance groups, organising protests and sending information to the media.
Then, she says, the interrogation became more violent.

A room without time
Seddiqi says she was taken into a dark room where her hands and feet were tied to a chair. She describes being subjected to electric shocks and beatings and losing consciousness. When she woke, she says she was struggling to breathe and had a severe headache. Her phone became one of the main tools used against her.
She had refused to give its password because it contained private photographs and family information. But, she says, interrogators threatened her family. Eventually, she gave them the password.
They searched her messages, photographs and videos, looking for the names of other activists and evidence of protests. Seddiqi says she was repeatedly told that she was part of the resistance and that she deserved to die.
Her detention was later documented by international human rights organizations. Amnesty International reported that she had been forcibly disappeared after her October 2023 arrest and later transferred to prison, where concerns were raised about her access to a lawyer, regular family contact and the risk of torture and other ill-treatment.
But for Seddiqi, the fear was not only about what might happen to her. It was also about what might happen to the people she loved.
When the family became part of the case
For nearly a month, Seddiqi says, she was kept largely isolated. She describes a dark, damp room monitored by cameras, repeated interrogations and long periods without proper sleep. Eventually, she was allowed to inform her family that she was being held. Her father, brother and brother-in-law came to see her.
According to Seddiqi, they were also detained and beaten. Her father was eventually released because of his age, heart problems and a broken hand. Her brother and brother-in-law were released later after elders intervened. The message was clear to her: her family could also pay a price for her activism. She says she was later transferred between detention facilities before being taken to Pul-e-Charkhi prison.

A sentence – and another kind of pressure
Seddiqi says her trial took place in Kabul. Her family and lawyer were not allowed to enter the courtroom. When she was asked what she had done, she told the court that she had protested for girls to return to school and university and for women to have their rights. At a later hearing, she was sentenced to two years in prison.
She rejected the sentence. She says she was beaten inside the courtroom and forced to provide a fingerprint. Her case was then sent to the Kabul provincial appeal process. Inside prison, she says, the conditions were harsh. There was little access to medical care, inadequate sleeping and bathing facilities, and poor quality food.
She also describes witnessing the mistreatment of other young women. Some women returned from court with visible injuries, she says. Others were deeply distressed.
Who gets to tell the story?
The hardest moments were not always the interrogations. Sometimes they were the moments when she had nothing to do but wait. At one point, she asked for a Quran because she wanted something to hold on to spiritually. She says she was refused.
Her eyesight deteriorated after her eyes became severely swollen, and she says she received little medical attention. Still, other women in prison became a source of strength. They told her not to lose hope. They shared what little they had. They taught each other handicrafts and knitting.
“We are your family,” she remembers them telling her. In April 2024, Seddiqi appeared at a Taliban-organized press conference after her release. There, she said that she had not been tortured and that her health was good. But women’s rights activists disputed the statement, saying she had been pressured to confess.
The two accounts left a question hanging over what happened behind the prison walls. Seddiqi’s own account of her detention is starkly different. She says she was subjected to beatings, threats and electric shocks and that she was pressured to accept a narrative that contradicted her experience. The question is not only what happened to her.
It is also who gets to tell the story.

Freedom did not feel like freedom
Seddiqi was released in early April 2024, after months in detention. But she says the conditions surrounding her release placed her under another form of pressure. She describes an arrangement in which her family was required to provide guarantees and she was expected to accept restrictions on her movements and activities.
Soon after returning home, she says, her family received another call from Taliban intelligence ordering her and the guarantors to report. The family became afraid.
They switched off their phones. At night, Seddiqi left with little more than a change of clothes. She eventually reached Kandahar and found a smuggler who helped her cross into Pakistan.
She had escaped prison. But she had not escaped fear.
Exile did not silence the fear
In Pakistan, Seddiqi says, she spent nearly a year unable to return to the activism that had once defined her life. She was undocumented, economically insecure and afraid that anything she said publicly could put her family at greater risk.
She says relatives sometimes encouraged her to continue speaking, while at other times they blamed her for bringing danger and pressure on the family. Then came another devastating development.
Her brother and brother-in-law, who had guaranteed her release, were deported from Pakistan to Afghanistan. Seddiqi says they are now hiding in another province. She fears that if she speaks too loudly, the Taliban could find them.
Their children are also affected. She says they face restrictions on their ability to study, work and move freely. For Seddiqi, this has created a painful sense of responsibility.
She survived prison. But people she loves are still living with the consequences.

The cost of speaking
Seddiqi says she is no longer the same person who entered prison. She describes problems with her memory and concentration, weakness, breathing difficulties and changes in her eyesight.
She also remembers noticing that her hair had begun turning white during her time in solitary confinement. But the most difficult change, she says, has been the loss of the confidence and energy she once had.
Sometimes, when relatives pressure her to stop posting videos, she finds it difficult even to breathe normally.
Yet she continues.
She records and shares messages supporting Afghan women and criticising Taliban restrictions. She does not always have reliable access to a phone or SIM card. She knows that every public message can have consequences.
Still, she posts.
More than a victim
Seddiqi’s story is not only a story of detention. It is also a story of what happens when a woman refuses to allow imprisonment to become the final definition of her life. She does not describe herself only as a victim.
She talks about the women who remained beside her in prison.
She talks about the activists who continued resisting.
She talks about young people who, despite extreme conditions, continue to resist in the Hindu Kush mountains.
When she sees their images, she says, she asks herself how she could surrender when others are standing in such difficult circumstances.
“If they stand under such hardship, I should not surrender,” is how she describes her determination.

What freedom means now
For Seddiqi, freedom is bigger than simply reopening schools or allowing women to return to work. She says she no longer trusts promises of education or employment made under a system that controls women through fear. What she wants is a society in which women can study, work, move freely and participate in public life without having to negotiate their basic rights with those who hold power.
She wants Afghan women to be heard. And she wants the world to understand that the women who protested after the Taliban takeover did not simply disappear when the streets became dangerous.
Some were detained.
Some were forced into silence.
Some fled.
Some continued speaking from exile.
Seddiqi is one of them.
The voice that came out
The Taliban could close the prison door.
They could take her phone.
They could interrogate her.
They could sentence her.
They could pressure her into silence.
But when Seddiqi left prison, something remained with her: the voice she had used before her arrest to demand education, freedom and dignity for Afghan women.
That voice is quieter now.
It carries fear.
It carries the weight of exile and the danger facing her family.
But it has not disappeared.
The prison door opened.
The story did not end there.
(Photo note for editors: All photographs in this submission were supplied by Manizha Seddiqi with permission for publication.)
About the Author: Fariba Faizi is an Afghan journalist and women’s rights advocate whose work focuses on documenting the experiences of Afghan women and human rights defenders. Her reporting explores the impact of repression, conflict, and restrictions on women’s lives and freedoms. She holds a Master’s degree in Diplomacy, Law and Commerce and has worked in journalism and civil society.